ANSWERED on Wed 28 Jan 2009 - 1:10 am UTC by byrd
Home » Miscellaneous » #2641
Please carefully read the Disclaimer and Terms & conditions.Actions: Add Comment
Asked by gnossie on Tue 27 Jan 2009 - 6:16 am UTC:
I have a friend from the Third World whom I am teaching to drive. This is an adult we're talking about with no experience. I'm aware that many driving manuals and quizzes are available online. In particular, the California DMV website and manual seems well-done. But what I'm looking for is a simulator that helps my friend with some basic safety stuff: kind of like Need for Speed, but not a racing game. A serious game that helps you learn about driving, safety, and the rules of the road. I've seen something for sale: a UK game called "Bus Simulator." http://www.amazon.co.uk/GSP-Bus-Simulator-PC-DVD/dp/B00171NOTA/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=videogames&qid=1233036834&sr=8-1 Well, is there something like that for a car? (U.S.-style driving on the right, though). When I first heard about Bus Simulator, I thought it a ridiculous idea. But then I started thinking . . . if there were something like this for a car, it might actually help someone to learn to drive, in the same way that any hours spent Microsoft Flight Simulator couldn't hurt an aspiring pilot. So . . . I am willing to pay for software, or look at on-line applications (I have broadband.) Can you think of anything that would fit the bill?
Question clarification by gnossie on Tue 27 Jan 2009 - 6:18 am UTC:
Note that I'm aware of this http://www.amazon.com/Driving-Simulator-SIMURIDE-automatic-transmission-PC/dp/B00119MXVI/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=videogames&qid=1233037044&sr=8-1 although this is damn pricey.
Answer by Researcher byrd on Wed 28 Jan 2009 - 1:10 am UTC:
Hi Gnossie, Driving simulation is becoming increasingly sophisticated and more widely used in actual driving schools as well as in high schools and colleges with driver education programs, many of which are beginning to use in-car, PC-based and/or standalone 3D simulators to replace part of the traditional on the street training, although these are probably priced way out of reach of the average home user. High end simulators are also available for research purposes both by universities, and other entities such as the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS). Simulators for personal and home use are beginning to appear, however, though they haven't quite reached the same market level as flight simulators, and most are still geared toward gaming and racing rather than straightforward street or highway driving and/or training. Nevertheless, in addition to the pricey "Simuride," (company homepage here: http://www.aplusbsoftware.com/ ), which is quite a ground-breaking product according to the reviews, I've located some other products that appear to meet the criteria for a driving game or simulator that can assist the user in learning to drive, or with at least some aspect of learning to drive. They're listed below, somewhat arbitrarily, but roughly in order of either ease of use or apparent usefulness for your purpose (in my opinion of course) so be sure to look through them yourself. I hope that one or more will meet your needs. I've also included a few just for fun or information's sake that are probably not practical for your purpose, but that I thought you might like to read about anyway. If you need further assistance, please Request a Clarification and I'll be happy to respond. Best wishes, Byrd ========================================================================= Gran Turismo Garnering rave reviews, the standard car driving simulator/game in the US appears to be a Playstation game called Gran Turismo. Gran Turismo 4 is the current version. Although designed as a game and primarily geared toward racing, it is nevertheless adaptable enough to also be used as a serious simulator. Its tagline is even "the real driving simulator." It has realistic courses (including New York City and the Grand Canyon), controls, cars, and car physics that provide realistic handling characteristics. It can be used either as a standalone program or interactively online. It is available from Amazon as well as other large retailers such as Wal-Mart, Best Buy and Sears. Retail locations are available via links from the main site. The price is probably closer to what you had in mind, starting at around $20. http://www.us.playstation.com/GranTurismo4/ http://www.us.playstation.com/PS2/Games/Gran_Turismo_4 Need For Speed (NFS) Pro Street Similar to GT4 though not as well reviewed, nor quite as feature-laden or popular, this is a PC-based (also available for various gaming systems) downloadable game with a free trial that also provides realistic cars, controls and driving situations. It can be played alone or interactively online. However, it too focuses on racing, in this case apparently touring car racing. While not really a driving trainer, it does provide practice in handling in various situations. Wikipedia gives a pretty good description of the game, so I've included that link as well. http://www.ea.com/prostreet/news.jsp?locale=us&skip_intro=1 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Need_for_speed_prostreet Drivers Ed Game Developed by Drivers Ed, a company that provides in-car and online driver education for a number of states, this game is not a serious simulator but provides free, fun online driving practice from an actual driving school. There are other helpful games as well, including the "DMV Game" and the "Drivers Ed Lottery" game. http://driversed.com/Games/drivers-ed-game.aspx Drivers Ed Online Game Simple Shockwave-based online driver's ed game that uses the arrow keys to provide practice in driving forward and back, turning, parallel parking, parking in a parking space, stopping and merging. Includes "Ed," your friendly driving instructor. http://www.mofunzone.com/online_games/driversed.shtml# Driver's Ed Direct This free online game provides practice with parking skills. http://www.driverseddirect.com/game/ Road Trip 2008 Driving simulator that uses actual terrain data and photo realistic texturing combined with actual highway alignment data to provide a realistic driving experience. It strives to allow the driver to feel completely in control. Has a free demo version featuring I-70 west of Denver. http://www.roadtrip2000.com/ Car World "CarWorld is a small driving simulator/demo I use to test various things of interest. It was mostly developed when I was a student. It is released with the full source code under the GNU General Public License." Free to download, runs on Windows, Linux and Macs. Another download sources says it's "an interesting game where you get to try a new kind of car." http://carworld.sourceforge.net/ Streetwise Produced by Chrysler, this "online 3D game is a third-person driving simulator that uses new Chrysler models to propel players into a totally immersive learning experience with real-world driving conditions in a large city and its surrounding areas. The game includes five missions which cover the three levels of learning permits recognized by the driver education programs of most states. Making the right decisions and mastering basic and advanced driving skills will allow the player to progress through the game. Each level gives the player new liberties and new responsibilities." http://www.chrysler.com/games/rrt_streetwise.html Test Drive Unlimited Another PC-based racing game (also available for other platforms) with online multiplayer capability, this game allows the user to shop for and purchase their vehicle, then either participate in races, or drive Hawaiian roads with/against other players. There are over 90 models of car to choose from, and all are fully customizable. Doesn't exactly teach rules of the road since it says "you set the rules, time and place," but may help with learning control and handling. http://www.testdriveunlimited.com/index.html Profiler This is a professional level training simulator that comes with a variety of pricing options making it feasible for possible home use, as the smallest licensing package starts at under $100. However, it is "not intended as a tutorial to teach new drivers how to operate a motor vehicle, nor it a driver education program for teaching the rules of the road. Profiler can be used as an assessment tool to validate novice driver training, and is very useful as a risk management tool to help identify drivers who may require additional training attention." http://www.profiler-vr.com/ Home Simulator Company Products include standalone driving simulator chairs and accessories for home use. Prices are a little high, comparable to that Amazon product you found, though not quite in the league of the driving school level simulators, but you sure get a lot for the money with these systems, including software, wheels, chairs and more. Check them out: http://www.myhomesimulator.com/products.html Toyota Prius Simulator Here's a driving simulator for the Toyota Prius, presumably designed to help customers and prospective customers learn the specifics of driving this hybrid vehicle. It's online, interactive, helpful and fun. Take a look: http://www.wind.sannet.ne.jp/m_matsu/prius/ThsSimu/index_i18n.html GeoQuake This 2D game provides a top down view and several vehicles to choose from, including cars, buses and trailers. Controls are simple, there are no goals, and there is also a Google Maps version that lets you virtually drive the world. http://geoquake.jp/en/webgame/DrivingSimulator/ 18 Wheels of Steel and more SCS Software produces these simulation games featuring trucks and buses, not cars, but that come with high reviews and offer a look at another type of road driving. There are several different games available, including "18 Wheels of Steel: American Long Haul" and "18 Wheels of Steel Haulin'." There is also a Euro Truck simulator and a Bus Driver game. http://www.scssoft.com/ Drive Like a Kennedy Just for fun, not a serious simulator, "avoid hitting guardrails and traffic as you make your way to Capitol Hill while under the influence. http://www.heavygames.com/drivelikeakennedy/showgame.asp 3D Driving School Alas, this is not specific to the US but rather an international game/simulator, providing opportunity to drive in London, Madrid, Paris and Berlin. Included just for completeness' sake as it appears to be a great simulator and gets rave reviews. http://www.3dfahrschule.de/uk_index.htm NADS The title of the "world's most advanced ground vehicle simulator" probably goes to the "National Advanced Driving Simulator" at the University of Iowa. Not available to the general public or for purchase, but rather used for research, still any list of car driving simulators would be incomplete without at least a mention of this facility. Though the main simulator is a 3D full motion standalone machine, there are several other lesser simulators including "the NADS MiniSim, a low-cost PC-based portable simulator." The university does recruit study participants, however, so if your friend might be interested in signing up, I've also provided a link to that option. http://www.nads-sc.uiowa.edu/ http://www.nads-sc.uiowa.edu/forms/recruiting.htm And just to round things out, here are a few of the higher end products marketed to driving schools, just for your information: AutoSim http://www.autosim.no/ Beta Research BR Series of Driving Simulators http://www.beta-research.com/drivingsimulator.html STISIM http://www.stisimdrive.com/our-solutions/training-solutions.html Virage Simulation Driver Training http://www.viragesimulation.com/en/drivingSchool.html XPI Simulation http://www.xpisimulation.com/products/driving.htm
Actions: Add Comment
|
Frequently Asked Questions | Terms & Conditions | Disclaimer | Privacy Policy | Contact Us | Spread the word! © 2010 Uclue Ltd |